[New Post] ARC Review: Keep Tuscany by Kelly Kay


Title: Keep Tuscany

Author: Kelly Kay

Page count: 401

Published: August 26th, 2024

Publisher: Grey’s Promo

Genre: Second Chance

Received: From the publisher in exchange for an honest review

Rating: 5/5



What if you got a star-crossed Italian do-over?

Single Dad, Second Chance, Soulmates, Friends To Lovers

When life gives you lemons, make limoncello. 

Colt’s eyes are exactly the same—amber-rimmed in green and electric—as they take me like he did fourteen years ago. We share this moment as if it’s before there was heart-shattering honor, duty, doing the right thing and leaving us both broken. Time, distance, and pain all evaporate in this moment. I was beginning to feel like Under The Tuscan Sun and Beach Music lied to me, but Italy might actually be magic. Neither of us should logically be here, but here we are, trapped in each other’s gaze in the middle of Tuscany.

My mother remarked, “Maggie, you’re being ridiculous, a country can’t heal a broken heart.” 

But what’s really messed up is that even though my husband left me for our mixed doubles pickleball partners, my heart’s not broken. It was never whole enough to give it to my ex-husband because it never healed from when Colt had to marry someone else.

Now I’m sitting here in a falling-apart Tuscan villa with a way overabundant lemon grove and a possible mongoose living in the walls, terrified of all I left behind, clutching at the tatters of tomorrow, but I can’t stop smiling. Maybe, finally, I’m allowed to fully open my heart for the first time since he had to marry someone else. Now it’s my turn. Maybe this time, I’ll get to love him forever. Maybe healing a broken heart means getting a second chance. Or maybe I’m meant to remain shattered.  I hope not.

The Boston Brothers: A Second Chance series are interconnected standalone stories featuring the lives and loves of six guys who are either brothers or brothers from another mother and the women they were lucky enough to find, screw it up and then find again.



Colt and Maggie meet in Paris when they are studying abroad, and you can tell they are meant to be. One day they are forced apart by things in life. Some years later they have a second chance meeting on accident, the accident lead them to be able to heal their hearts with one another they were one another’s perfect caretaker. While reading there is a definite roller coaster that you get taken on and I loved every minute of it. Colt and Maggie may be my favourite in the series thus far.



Leave a comment


Leave a comment